APSN Banner

The end of constitutional illegitimacy

Source
Tempo Editorial - November 16, 2026

Political karma has caught up with Gibran Rakabuming Raka and his father, Joko Widodo. Having ascended to power two years ago by circumventing presidential election candidacy rules, Gibran stepped down after the manipulation of his diploma requirements was exposed in the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court.

History records that after bending the rules, Gibran was elected vice president thanks to his father, who was then the sitting president. Failing to extend his own term in office, Jokowi pushed his son toward Prabowo to take Gibran as his running mate despite having to break ranks with the Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P), the party that had nurtured Jokowi's political career since his days in Solo. Jokowi then mobilized state resources to secure victory for the pair.

The convergence of interests between Jokowi, who harbored ambitions to retain power through his son, and Prabowo, who had long coveted the presidency, gave rise to a dual-power arrangement. Even after leaving office, Jokowi maintained influence within Prabowo's cabinet, particularly since several of Prabowo's ministers were former aides to Jokowi. Early in his administration, Prabowo appeared to give Jokowi leeway to meddle in government affairs.

Yet every honeymoon comes to an end. Dual power inevitably breeds dual loyalties. The revelation of illegal wiretapping targeting Prabowo by Gen. Listyo Sigit Prabowo during his tenure as Chief of the National Police signaled a power struggle. The exposure of that case, which culminated in allegations of a treason plot, marked the peak of friction between the "two suns" at the pinnacle of power.

Just days after the illegal wiretapping and treason allegations came to light, Gibran resigned from office. Politicians' plans to impeach Gibran had already been gaining rapid momentum after the Supreme Court annulled his high school diploma equivalency certificate. However, the wiretapping of Prabowo and the treason allegations involving Listyo, a key Jokowi loyalist, became the decisive factors that shattered any plans by Gibran and his father to fight back. The scandal cornered the "Solo faction," leaving them with no room to maneuver.

Gibran then became the fall guy. Politicians sought a scapegoat for their own political "crimes" of three years ago. Back then, they feigned deafness and blindness regarding the flaws in Gibran's candidacy, even scrambling to defend him. Now, once the political winds shifted against them, they spat Gibran out. Out of sheer decency, those who profited from the Prabowo-Gibran victory should have resigned from their posts en masse.

Prabowo is no exception. He was the primary beneficiary of Jokowi's hunger for power. Without Jokowi's backing in the 2024 presidential election, Prabowo would likely have lost. His electability and campaign war chest swelled following the endorsement of the incumbent president – not to mention the state "support" deployed during the campaign, including social assistance funds and the state apparatus. Now that the election two years ago has been proven morally and procedurally flawed, Prabowo ought to step down as well.

Many assume that with Gibran ousted and Jokowi politically isolated, the nation is returning to the constitutional path, or that Prabowo will no longer face interference from Jokowi and his political network. Undeniably, Prabowo has benefited from the recent political turmoil. At the very least, his plummeting approval ratings have rebounded. He can easily claim that for the past two years, his administration was hampered by the Solo group.

Behind all this, however, a far worse outcome looms: power becoming increasingly concentrated in Prabowo's hands, ultimately sliding Indonesia into autocracy. For ordinary citizens, therefore, Gibran's resignation offers little real benefit.

With elite rivalries gone, and with checks and balances from formal political institutions already dulled, Prabowo's administration now appears to have no brakes. He will have free rein to control the state. Unless citizens unite to hold the government accountable, an already chaotic administration of the country will fall into even deeper ruin.

– Read the complete story in Tempo English Magazine

Source: https://en.tempo.co/read/2123712/the-end-of-constitutional-illegitimac

Country