APSN Banner

Uncover the conspiracy behind Gibran's candidacy

Source
Tempo Editorial - November 12, 2026

The Supreme Court's ruling declaring invalid the educational equivalency letter issued for Gibran Rakabuming Raka should serve as a starting point for investigating the process behind his candidacy. In Decision No. 742 K/TUN/2026, the Supreme Court granted Subhan Palal's cassation appeal and his lawsuit challenging Education Ministry Letter No. 9149/D.D1/KS/2019. The ruling raises questions about the validity of the documents used to meet the requirements for Gibran's candidacy.

The issue concerns not only the equivalency letter but also the General Elections Commission (KPU) regulation that formed part of the process. Article 18, Paragraph 3 of KPU Regulation No. 19/2023 exempts candidates who already hold university degrees from submitting proof of graduation from a foreign senior high school. Yet Article 169(r) of the General Elections Law requires presidential and vice-presidential candidates to have completed senior high school or its equivalent.

The process through which this exemption was introduced raises questions. Ahmad Doli Kurnia, then Chair of the House of Representatives' Commission II, said the KPU submitted three draft regulations on September 15, 2023, none of which contained the exemption. Four days later, the KPU sent a follow-up letter containing four draft regulations. According to Doli, the provision appeared only in the additional draft and was not discussed at Commission II's hearing on September 20.

A different account was given by KPU member Idham Holik. He said the provision had already appeared in Article 19, Paragraph 2 of the draft during the consignment meeting on September 19, before being changed to Article 18, Paragraph 3 after harmonization. Former KPU Chair Hasyim Asy'ari also denied that the provision had been surreptitiously inserted. These conflicting accounts demand transparency: the minutes of the consignment meeting, the follow-up letter, the initial drafts, and the harmonization documents must be made public. The public has the right to know who proposed the provision and how it found its way into the regulation.

If there was a deliberate effort to design regulations or use documents to clear a candidate who did not meet the requirements, the case cannot be treated merely as an administrative dispute. The suspected criminal offenses warrant investigation. The inquiry must not stop at the KPU and ministry officials. Gibran and his father, Joko Widodo, could also be questioned if evidence emerges linking them to the process.

Article 391 of the new Criminal Code governs the forgery and use of documents containing false or falsified information. Article 20 regulates participation in criminal offenses, including those who order or take part in committing a crime. This means that, if the elements of the offenses are established, legal liability is not limited to administrative officials.

A criminal investigation is distinct from impeachment. Articles 7A and 7B of the 1945 Constitution govern the removal of a president or vice president through the House of Representatives, the Constitutional Court, and the People's Consultative Assembly. The Supreme Court's ruling does not automatically remove Gibran from office. The National Awakening Party's (PKB) discussion of impeachment during an online meeting is part of the political debate, but any removal process must still follow constitutional procedures.

This case also has implications for relations among political elites and the cohesion of Prabowo Subianto's coalition. Parties supporting the government cannot continue to hide behind pragmatic calculations. The entire chain of decision-making must be made public, and anyone proven to have been involved must be held accountable. The alleged manipulation of the candidacy process must not end in a backroom deal among political elites.

– Read the complete story in Tempo English Magazine

Source: https://en.tempo.co/read/2123476/uncover-the-conspiracy-behind-gibrans-candidac

Country