APSN Banner

Passing the buck: Tamalanrea residents visit Danantara, refuse to live next to pollution and threats to their living space

Source
Indonesian Forum for the Environment (WALHI) South Sulawesi Press Release - November 13, 2026

Jakarta – A group of residents from Tamalanrea in Makassar traveled to Jakarta to meet with Danantara. They took this step because, after approximately two years of campaigning against the location of the PLTSa, they have yet to find a way to resolve the conflict.

A representative of the Tamalanrea community said "We came to Jakarta, willing to take a boat and leave our children and families behind, to fight for our rights. We've staged several protests and held meetings at the Regional People's Representative Council and the Makassar Mayor's Office, but we felt like we were being passed back and forth. Finally, the Mayor of Makassar asked us to come to Danantara, so that's why we're here. The waste-to-energy plant is very close to our homes." Ani said.

The residents' trip to Jakarta was prompted by a statement made by Makassar Mayor Munafri Arifuddin on October 20, 2026, in which he noted that the city government had requested the termination of the project contract, but that the authority to decide on its continuation rested with Danantara. However, during the hearing, the residents received a different explanation. Denera's Vice President of Stakeholder Relations, Averyadi Setiawan, stated that the determination of the project location falls under the city government's authority and that Denera would not overstep that authority. According to him, based on Presidential Regulation No. 109 of 2025, Denera's duties are limited to technical and economic assessments as well as the selection of a business entity.

"The discrepancy in these statements reveals a lack of clarity regarding the responsibilities of the various parties in ensuring the protection of the community's rights. Residents, who have repeatedly voiced their opposition, are instead faced with a passing-the-buck situation, while the threats to their homes and environmental safety have yet to be definitively resolved," Reveal Nurul Fadli Gaffar, Head of the Just Energy Transition Division at WALHI South Sulawesi.

This back-and-forth over jurisdiction is not the first of its kind. The Makassar PSEL contract was signed in September 2024 without involving residents, who only found out about it through limited outreach via WhatsApp in July 2025. Last May, the Minister of Finance actually urged the city government not to relocate the site. The PT Sarana Utama Synergy (PT SUS) consortium even announced that the groundbreaking would take place later this year. To date, there has not been a single official decision canceling the project in Tamalanrea.

The project site directly borders Kampung Mula Baru, Tamala'lang, and the Alamanda Housing Complex, with no buffer zone. Within a one-kilometer radius, there are at least 1,388 homes, six schools, one early childhood education center, and one community health center. A study in China suggests a safe distance of about 1.5 kilometers from residential areas. A total of 1,576 residents from the three villages have signed a petition opposing the project. Makassar's waste is also unsuitable for incineration. About 65 percent consists of wet food scraps, which make combustion unstable and increase the risk of dioxin and furan emissions.

"The waste problem must not be solved by shifting environmental and health risks into residential areas. Changes to funding or institutional structures must not become an excuse to ignore issues that have already arisen," Fadhli added.

What the residents of Tamalanrea feared has already happened at the Putri Cempo Solar Power Plant in Surakarta. A study by WALHI titled "Sowing the Seeds of Destruction" notes that the plant's liquid waste is discharged into the Jengglong River, which flows into the Bengawan Solo River; bottom ash – classified as hazardous waste (B3) – is piled in open areas; and nearby residents complain of coughing and shortness of breath. Its operating profit over 20 years could be as low as a loss of Rp617 billion, even before loan interest is paid.

At the national level, the government has allocated Rp89 trillion for 33 PSELs. PLN is required to purchase electricity at approximately US$0.20 per kWh for 30 years, which is far above the cost of electricity generation. The difference may have to be covered by the state budget.

"It's already happened in Solo, and to this day, the residents around Putri Cempo are the ones bearing the brunt of it. We mustn't let this happen in Makassar as well. Who is this PSN actually being built for – the residents or the investors?" said Paksi Lalang Sambegana, National Executive Campaigner for WALHI.

WALHI points out that Law No. 18 of 2008 prioritizes waste reduction over incineration. Therefore, before the project proceeds, the government and Danantara must transparently disclose the total costs to be borne by PLN and the state budget during the contract period. "Danantara handles public funds, so it must be used carefully. Burning trash is expensive – it comes at the cost of residents' health, ecological damage, and a drain on the state budget," Paksi added.

Furthermore, Denera, as the entity responsible for the investment and development of the PSEL, cannot shirk its responsibility simply on the grounds that site selection falls under the authority of the city government. Denera must ensure that the projects it supports do not harm the environment or violate the rights of the community, including the right to a clean and healthy environment, health, safety, and living space. From the perspective of human rights and ecological justice, a project's feasibility cannot be assessed solely on technical and economic grounds but must also consider the protection of residents' rights and the prevention of shifting development risks onto the community.

"Denera cannot hide behind the division of authority to avoid responsibility. Public investments and strategic projects must not come at the expense of the environment or citizens' rights. We must not allow the benefits of these projects to be enjoyed by only a select few, while the public is forced to bear the risks to their health and ecological damage," Paksi said firmly.

Therefore, the residents of Tamalanrea are demanding that all stakeholders, including Denera and BPI Danantara, stop passing the buck and immediately issue an official decision to halt the PSEL project in Tamalanrea.

Indonesian Forum for the Environment (WALHI)14 Tegal Parang Utara Street, Mampang Prapatan, South Jakarta
Email: informasi@walhi.or.id, Instagram: @walhi.nasional, X: @walhi.nasional
TikTok: @walhi.nasional
Cell Phone: (+628115501980)

Source: https://www.walhi.or.id/en/saling-lempar-kewenangan-warga-tamalanrea-datangi-danantara-tolak-bertetangga-dengan-polusi-dan-ancaman-atas-ruang-hidu

Country