Antalya – In Indonesia's national statement during the high-level segment of COP31 in Antalya, Turkey, the President's Special Envoy for Climate and Energy, Hashim Djojohadikusumo, called for COP31 to be remembered not for its promises, but for its actions. WALHI believes the speech itself was full of promises that have been broken on the ground: not clearing forests for agriculture, protecting national parks and endangered species, and building 100 GW of solar power. Forest and land fires (karhutla) were also dismissed as merely the result of El Nino.
The promise not to clear forests has even been broken from within the government itself. Deputy Coordinating Minister for Food Hanif Faisol Nurofiq raised the possibility of using land previously affected by forest and land fires for National Strategic Projects (PSN), with a target of 6 million hectares for food crops and 2 million hectares for sugarcane plantations for the E50 program.
"In Antalya, the government says it won't clear forests. In Jakarta, the government is preparing land that was previously burned for the National Strategic Projects (PSN). If burned land can be repurposed, burning becomes the cheapest way to clear land. This isn't a climate solution – it's an incentive for arsonists," said Dana Tarigan, Head of the Department of Strategic Communications and Networking at WALHI National.
The El Nino explanation also obscures who is most responsible. From August through October 2026, WALHI recorded approximately 74,000 hotspots and fire points across 30 provinces. The majority of fires occurred on licensed land: 13,576 hotspots in PBPH concessions during the same period. WALHI has reported 372 companies linked to forest and land fires. WALHI's monitoring also identified 446 high-confidence hotspots across 12 concessions associated with carbon projects between January 1 and September 14, 2026. Government projects themselves were also affected by the fires. From January through October 2026, WALHI recorded 8,324 hotspots in Papua, 2,747 of which were located in PSN areas: 1,834 in food estates and 913 in sugarcane plantations (energy estates). In Merauke, 674 hotspots from January through August 2026 were located in food estate clusters directly overseen by the Coordinating Ministry for Food Security and the Ministry of Agriculture.
"The Deputy Coordinating Minister for Food spoke about restoring burned land, even though 674 hotspots actually appeared in the food estate clusters overseen by his own ministry. The government cannot be both the firefighter and the arsonist. Government projects are the first thing that should be investigated," said Dana.
Uli Arta Siagian, Campaign Coordinator for WALHI National, also stated that claims regarding the protection of conservation areas do not align with reality. In his national statement, Hashim noted that the government is expanding protected areas and national parks and investing in conservation efforts to protect orangutans, elephants, and Sumatran tigers. In fact, WALHI's preliminary data shows that 13 national parks were affected by fires between January and September 2026, covering a total area of approximately 83,315 hectares.
Wasur National Park in Merauke – the same regency as the PSN food estate – saw the largest area burned, totaling 24,544 hectares. Next were Tambora National Park (17,358 hectares), Lorentz National Park (12,545 hectares), and Tanjung Puting National Park (11,608 hectares). Animals like Hashim have lost their homes: Tanjung Puting is an orangutan habitat, while Way Kambas–home to elephants and Sumatran tigers–saw 6,960 hectares burn.
"Hashim boasts about the orangutans, elephants, and tigers in Antalya, while their homes are burning in 13 national parks. Expanding national parks on paper means nothing if fires are allowed to spread from government concessions and projects into conservation areas," said Uli.
Hashim also mentioned the newly formed national agency for peatland and mangrove management, which reports directly to the President. However, the government itself dissolved the Peatland and Mangrove Restoration Agency (BRGM) on December 31, 2024, and then established the new agency following the major fires of 2026.
WALHI believes that peatland degradation cannot be resolved without addressing concessions, since most of the burned peatlands are located in licensed areas. Therefore, the BPGMN must operate without being restricted by concession or non-concession boundaries, and its mandate must include evaluations and recommendations for the revocation of permits. WALHI also questions the choice of the word "management" in the agency's name. Managing already-damaged peatlands only makes sense if the land is being prepared for a business permit. This concern becomes even more relevant given that the Deputy Coordinating Minister for Food has raised the possibility of using land previously affected by forest and land fires for the National Strategic Projects (PSN).
"If that's the case, well, it's the same thing – it will be a burden on the national budget. This agency will be a waste of resources," he cautioned, noting that without fundamental changes, the BPGMN will simply repeat the BRGM's fate. He emphasized that the agency's leadership must have a background in and understanding of peat," Uli added.
Hashim also noted that more than 25,000 residents were involved in fire prevention, and the number of forest rangers and firefighters was increased from 8,000 to 70,000. This narrative places the burden of prevention on the shoulders of residents, as if fires could come from anywhere. The fact is clear: most fires occur on licensed land. Yet not a single word is said about corporate responsibility.
"The government counts the firefighters on the podium, but forgets the children breathing in smoke and the farmers who are imprisoned. Those who protect the land are punished, while those who set fires actually have their land prepared for them. So what's the point of adding more guards and firefighters if corporations are still allowed to commit violations – even crimes?" said Uli.
Regarding the oceans, Hashim mentioned blue carbon in mangroves and seagrass beds, as well as efforts to protect 30% of the oceans for the benefit of coastal communities. In fact, approximately 750,000 hectares of Indonesia's 3.44 million hectares of mangroves are reported to be damaged or lost, while the government has already established a blue carbon market.
Regarding funding, WALHI agrees that developed countries should meet the new climate financing targets (NCQG). This funding is an obligation of developed countries as the largest contributors to emissions–it is not a commercial transaction. Therefore, WALHI rejects the approach of "opening all funding channels, including carbon pricing." Through carbon trading, developed countries and polluting corporations are essentially buying permission to continue emitting, while Indonesia's forests, peatlands, and coastlines are used as collateral. Funding must also take the form of grants, not debt that adds to the burden on the people.
Experience so far shows that climate funds are not reaching those who protect the forests. Of the GCF's US$103.78 million in result-based payment (RBP) funds, only about Rp500 billion had been disbursed as of July 2026. Climate funds channeled through the BPDLH have even flowed to the Medco Group for an energy plantation located on Marind indigenous territory in Merauke.
"Therefore, WALHI demands domestic policy reform, not just promises made at international forums. The government and stakeholders at COP31 must reject false solutions: do not make markets and profits the goal or the basis for developing climate action plans. Demonstrate concrete action by enacting a substantively sound Climate Justice Bill, an Indigenous Peoples Bill, and the Belem Action Mechanism; include emissions from fires and corporate liability in the FOLU Net Sink report and the 2030 deforestation accountability framework; channel climate finance as grants that directly reach communities, not as debt; and revise the NDC with a roadmap for coal reduction, including captive coal-fired power plants," Close the Fund.
Indonesian Forum for the Environment (WALHI)14 Tegal Parang Utara Street, Mampang Prapatan, South Jakarta
Email: informasi@walhi.or.id, Instagram: @walhi.nasional, X: @walhi.nasional, TikTok: @walhi.nasional
Cell Phone: (+628115501980)
