APSN Banner

Indonesia's Supreme Court overturns acquittal in Paniai massacre case

Source
Jubi - November 13, 2026

Nuevaterra Mambor, Nabire, Jubi – Indonesia's Supreme Court has granted an appeal lodged by the Attorney General's Office against the acquittal of the sole defendant in the Paniai massacre case, retired Major Isak Sattu, by the Makassar Human Right Court in South Sulawesi on 8 December 2022.

The case is registered under number 1/Pid.Sus-HAM/2022/PN Mks.

According to the Supreme Court's court administration website, kepaniteraan.mahkamahagung.go.id, the ruling was handed down on 10 November 2026.

The Supreme Court's decision, registered as case number 12000 K/Pid.Sus-HAM/2026, stated that the case has been decided and is currently undergoing the process of finalizing the written judgement.

The court's ruling states: "The appeal is granted. The lower court's decision is overturned and the Supreme Court adjudicates the case itself. The defendant is found guilty of the first and second charges and sentences is found guilty of the first and second charges and sentenced to five years' imprisonment.

"The defendant is also ordered to pay compensation of Rp250 million for each person killed, Rp210 million for each person moderately injured and Rp75 million for each person lightly injured. Charges P4 and P5 are dismissed."

Papua Legislative Council deputy speaker IV John NR Gobai, who appeared as a witness at the fourth hearing of the Paniai massacre trial at the Makassar District Court on 6 December 2022, welcomed the Supreme Court's decision.

"I commend the Attorney General's Office for appealing the acquittal handed down by the Makassar District Court on 8 December 2022," Gobai told Jubi in Nabire on Thursday, 12 November 2026.

He said the decision should serve as a lesson for all parties involved in advocating for victims of human rights abuses.

The Paniai case, he said, demonstrated that persistent efforts to pursue justice in humanitarian cases could eventually produce results.

Gobai acknowledged that the defendant's acquittal had been viewed by many as unjust. However, he said the Attorney General's Office deserved recognition for challenging the decision through an appeal.

"I commended the Attorney General's Office. I know many people there because, when I was involved in overseeing the Paniai case, I frequently visited its headquarters to ensure the case could proceed," he said.

Gobai urged all parties involved in advocation for human rights cases in Papua to continue monitoring legal proceedings and preparing reports that are accurate, comprehensive and systematically presented.

He said reports needed to clearly establish the elements of widespread violations and command responsibility to meet criteria for alleged gross human rights violations.

Gobai also thanked the Indonesian National Human Rights Commission (Komnas HAM) members serving at the time for classifying the Paniai massacre as a gross human rights violation.

"I also want to acknowledge and thank our NGO colleagues in Jakarta and Jayapura who have stood with us in monitoring the Paniai case. My thanks go to the activist and younger colleagues who were university students in Jayapura at the time," he said.

He specifically acknowledged student organizations and civil society groups, including FIM, BUK Kontras and AIDP, as well as Jubi and other media organizations.

"I also thanked our colleagues who served in the Papua Legislative Council during the 2014-2019 term. We worked together to monitor the Paniai case, and today we can read on the Supreme Court's website that an appeal decision has been handed down.

"Our solidarity and collective efforts were the foundation of our advocacy for the Paniai case. Our slogan at the time was, 'Paniai is us, and we are Paniai'. Now, we must build on that spirit and recognize that Papua is us, and we are Papua," Gobai said.

Gobai also expressed his gratitude to other parties he considered instrumental in pushing for a just outcome in the Paniai case.

They included the Paniai Regency Government, which supported efforts to resolve the case and provided relevant information, as well as doctors who treated the victims and hospital staff who gave evidence to Indonesia's Witness and Victi Protection Agency (LPSK).

He also acknowledged the Papua Regional Police, the National Police Headquarters and a team established by the Coordinating Minister for Political, Legal and Security Affairs at the time.

Gobai said problems in Papua needed to be addressed through collective advocacy involving all sectors of society.

He also called for the full implementation of Articles 45 and 46 of Papua's Special Autonomy Law.

Article 45 mandates the establishment of representative offices of Komnas HAM, Human Rights Court and a Truth and Reconciliation Commission (KKR) in Papua.

Article 40 provides for the establishment of truth and Reconciliation Commission to strengthen national unity through clarification of Papua's history and the development of reconciliation measures. Its composition and procedures are to be regulated through a presidential decree based on a proposal from the governor.

"This should serve a reminder to President Prabowo Subianto to establish a Human Rights Court within the Jayapura District Court, as well as a Truth and Reconciliation Commission, as mandated by the Special Autonomy Law," Gobai said.

Background to the Paniai massacre

The Makassar District Court previously acquitted retired Major Isak Sattu on 8 December 2022.

Satuu, a former liaison officer at the Paniai Military District Command (Kodim 1705/Paniai), had been charged with committing gross human rights violations in Paniai Regency, now part of Central Papua Province.

At the time, the panel of judges ordered that his rights be restored, ruling that the prosecution had failed to prove the charges of gross human rights violations brought against him.

Sattu was held responsible by prosecutors for his alleged role in the Paniai massacre, which occurred in front of the Enarotali Military Subdistrict Command (Koramil 1705-02/Enarotali) on 8 December 2014.

The shooting killed four people and injured 17 others.

The four people killed were Alpius Youw, who was shot in the upper left side of his back; Alpius Gobay, who was shot in the left abdomen, with the bullet exiting through the right side of his waist; Yulan Yeimo, who sustained a gunshot wound to the left abdomen, with the bullet exiting though the right side of his waist; and Simon Degei, who suffered a stab wound to the right side of his chest.

The events began on the afternoon of 7 December 2014, when several Indonesian military personnel allegedly assaulted Benyamin Kudiai, Yosafat Yeimo, Noak Gobai and Oktofince Yeimo at the Gunung Merah Christmas Hut, along the Enarotali-Madi road, about four kilometers from Enarotali, at around 5.30pm Papua time.

The assault angered the victims' relatives. The following morning, a group of people blocked the road in front of the Gunung Merah Christmas Hut.

At around 9am, Paniai Police officers led by the police operations chief, Commissioner Sukapdi, arrived at the location.

At the same time, about eight Indonesian Army soldiers from the 753rd Battalion's special unit, based in Nabire, were also present.

Around 100 people had gathered at the Christmas Hut, carrying traditional weapons including axes, machetes and bows and arrows, as well as stones and wooden sticks.

The crowd subsequently attacked the police vehicle driven by Sukapdi, who reported the situation to Paniai Deputy Police Chief Commissioner Hanafiah.

Hanafiah then ordered Sukapdi to withdraw all police officers and military personnel from the Gunung Merah Christmas Hut.

However, the soldiers said they would remain at the location.

Sukapdi repeated the withdrawal order, telling the soldiers: "Withdraw. Respect the chain of command."

The prosecution's indictment stated that, at the same time, another group of about 100 people had gathered at Karel Gobay Field, approximately six kilometres from the Christmas Hut.

The crowd at Karel Gobay Field carried traditional weapons, including bows and arrows, wooden sticks, axes and stones. They also performed waita, a traditional group dance in which participants run together in a circle, forming a rapidly rotating human formation.

Commissioner Hanafiah approached the crowd and attempted to negotiate with them, but the situation became increasingly difficult to control.

According to the indictment, while Hanafiah was negotiating with the angry residents, an Indonesian Army soldier shouted at the crowd: "You dogs and pigs, I'll do to you what I did last night."

At the same time, a series of gunshots rang out from below Karel Gobay Field. The crowd then rushed towards the direction from which the shots had come.

The indictment stated that members of the crowd damaged a vehicle driven by the commander of Company C of the 753rd Battalion, First Lieutenant Prasenta Imanuel Bangun, and attempted to seize his firearm.

Prasenta fired warning shots into the air.

Hanafiah then approached Prasenta and told him to stop shooting.

According to the prosecution's indictment, the crowd subsequently split into two groups, with some returning to Karel Gobay Field and others heading back to the Gunung Merah Christmas Hut.

Hanafiah later met with Paniai Deputy Regent Yohanis Youw and asked him to help calm the crowd at Karel Gobay Field.

The prosecution's indictment detailed the sequence of events leading up to the massacre.

When Hanafiah and Youw arrived at Karel Gobay Field, the crowd was performing waita before running past the Enarotali Military Subdistrict Command headquarters.

The indictment alleged that Sattu, the highest-ranking officer at the military post, ordered his soldiers to close the compound's gates.

Prosecutors said Sattu saw his soldiers retrieving firearms and live ammunition from the weapons storage facility but failed to prevent them from doing so.

A member of the Enarotali military command also asked residents who had climbed the compound's fence to come down.

However, one person continued climbing and shouted: "Just shoot me, because those weapons do not belong to you. They belong to the state."

The soldier then fired a warning shot and shouted to Sattu: "Commander, we need your instructions. Our post is under attack."

According to the prosecution's indictment, members of the Enarotali military command subsequently opened fire towards the crowd.

The soldiers also pursued people as they fled and stabbed several residents with bayonets.

Prosecutors alleged that Sattu had "failed to take appropriate and necessary action within the scope of his authority to prevent or stop his subordinates from carrying out shootings and acts of violence", resulting in the deaths of four people.

Source: https://en.jubi.id/indonesias-supreme-court-overturns-acquittal-in-paniai-massacre-case

Country