On 30 September 2026, Indonesian police arrested four Papuan students during the dispersal of a demonstration at the University of Science and Technology Jayapura (USTJ) campus in Padang Bulan, Abepura District, Jayapura City, Papua province.
The protest, which began at approximately 9.00 am, commemorated the 64th anniversary of the so-called Rome Agreement and included the raising of the Morning Star flag, a symbol of Papuan political identity and aspirations for independence. Police reportedly used tear gas and water cannons to disperse protesters following a confrontation over the removal of the flag. Police took four students, identified as Inios Enembe, Apniel Yagani (also reported as Jagani), Mikael Obaipa, and Frengky Salak (also reported as Fangky Salak), to Jayapura City Police Headquarters (Polresta Jayapura Kota). On 1 October 2026, police designated Enembe, Yagani and Obaipa as criminal suspects under Articles 192 and 234 of Indonesia's new Criminal Code (KUHP), exposing them to potentially severe criminal penalties, including life imprisonment or the death penalty under Article 192. Salak was subsequently released without charge. The incident raises serious concerns regarding freedom of expression, peaceful assembly, arbitrary deprivation of liberty and the use of national security legislation against peaceful political dissent in West Papua. The students' ages have not been established.
According to information published by local human rights and media organisations, the demonstration took place on the USTJ campus as students gathered to discuss the historical and political implications of the 1962 agreements concerning West Papua. Participants reportedly expressed concerns about the rights of Indigenous Papuans, called for stronger human rights protections and demanded the withdrawal of non-organic military personnel from West Papua. During the demonstration, students raised the Morning Star flag on a flagpole in the university grounds. Jayapura City Police Chief Senior Commissioner Fredrickus Maclarimboen subsequently arrived with police officers to have the flag removed. The attempt to lower the flag triggered protests among students and a confrontation with security personnel. According to the police chief, officers had attempted to negotiate with protesters before stones were thrown at police personnel. He stated that police responded with tear gas and water cannon to push back the crowd. These allegations concerning stone-throwing have not been independently verified, and the available information does not establish whether any of the four arrested students personally engaged in violence. The Catholic human rights organisation JPIC OFM Papua separately reported that officers from Jayapura City Police and the Papua Regional Police Mobile Brigade (Brimob) deployed tear gas inside the campus grounds.
During the police operation, officers arrested Inios Enembe, Apniel Yagani, Mikael Obaipa and Frengky Salak and transferred them to Jayapura City Police Headquarters for questioning. A legal assistance update dated 1 October 2026 indicated that questioning took place from approximately 7.00 pm until 12.06 am, although the precise dates covered by that overnight session were not specified. All four students were reportedly accompanied by legal counsel. Their legal assistance team included Yustina Haluk, Apilus Menufandu, Persila Heselo and Fredi Wamu. Police subsequently conducted a case assessment to determine each student's legal status.
On 1 October 2026, investigators formally designated Apniel Yagani, Inios Enembe and Mikael Obaipa as criminal suspects. According to Reinhart Kmur, a lawyer representing the Papua Coalition for Law Enforcement and Human Rights, the three underwent further formal questioning between 3.00 pm and 9.20 pm that day. Their statements were recorded in official police investigation reports (Berita Acara Pemeriksaan, BAP). Investigators reportedly invoked Article 192 of Law No. 1 of 2023 on acts intended to separate part or all of Indonesia's territory from the state, along with Article 234 on desecrating or dishonouring the Indonesian national flag. The fourth student, identified in the legal assistance update as Frengky Salak and in a subsequent media report as Fangky Salak, was questioned as a witness and released after police reportedly found no evidence of criminal conduct attributable to him. No verified information was available on the three suspects' subsequent release, continued detention, indictment or trial status at the time of preparation of this report.
The arrests also generated a dispute between the university administration and the student representative body concerning the identity and academic status of the accused. In a statement reported on 6 October 2026, the USTJ Student Executive Board (Badan Eksekutif Mahasiswa, BEM USTJ) rejected an earlier assertion by the university rector that the individuals involved in raising the Morning Star flag were not USTJ students. BEM Vice-President Luis Kitok Kasipka stated that all three accused were enrolled students and called upon the university administration to verify their status through official academic records rather than unsubstantiated allegations about external organisational involvement. According to the student body, Apniel Yagani was a third-semester Information Systems student, Inios Enembe was a fifth-semester Government Studies student who reportedly served as the demonstration's field coordinator, and Mikael Obaipa was a fifth-semester International Relations student who reportedly acted as the person responsible for the protest. BEM USTJ also denied that it had agreed with the rector's position, stating that no prior consultation or formal agreement had taken place.
The student representatives emphasised that universities should provide an environment in which students can examine contested historical narratives, express political opinions and engage in critical debate without intimidation or stigmatisation. They urged the university administration to engage constructively with students, clarify the disputed statements and coordinate with law enforcement authorities to ensure the protection and fair treatment of those facing criminal proceedings. The disagreement over the students' enrolment status is particularly relevant to concerns about academic freedom and the protection of political expression on university campuses.
Human rights analysis
Freedom of expression and peaceful assembly
The criminal investigation against the three students raises substantial concerns under Articles 19 and 21 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), which Indonesia ratified through Law No. 12 of 2005. Article 19 protects the right to express political opinions, including views that challenge government policies, constitutional arrangements and prevailing interpretations of history. Article 21 guarantees the right of peaceful assembly, subject only to restrictions prescribed by law that are necessary and proportionate to legitimate public interests. These guarantees extend to political demonstrations organised in educational institutions, including those addressing controversial questions of territorial status and self-determination.
The United Nations Human Rights Committee, in General Comment No. 37 (2020), explicitly recognises that the use of flags, banners and other symbols generally constitutes a legitimate form of expression. Paragraph 51 provides that such expressions should ordinarily remain protected even where symbols evoke a painful or controversial historical past. Restrictions may be justified in exceptional circumstances involving symbols directly and predominantly associated with incitement to discrimination, hostility or violence. Moreover, paragraph 49 clarifies that the right of peaceful assembly protects political opposition, challenges to governmental authority and the peaceful pursuit of self-determination. Consequently, displaying the Morning Star flag cannot, by itself, establish that participants engaged in violence or committed a legitimate national security offence.
Although police reported that stones were thrown during the confrontation, this allegation does not automatically deprive the entire demonstration of its peaceful character. Under paragraphs 17-19 of General Comment No. 37, isolated acts of violence by particular participants must not be attributed indiscriminately to all protesters or organisers. Criminal responsibility must be based on credible evidence of individual conduct. The available information does not establish that Enembe, Jagani or Obaipa personally engaged in violence, incited violent acts or directed others to attack police officers.
The reported use of tear gas and water cannon also requires scrutiny under international standards governing law enforcement during assemblies. Law enforcement officials must apply principles of legality, necessity, proportionality, precaution and non-discrimination. The authorities must establish whether dispersal was genuinely required, whether less intrusive measures were feasible and whether the use of potentially harmful crowd-control equipment was proportionate to any actual threat. The available reports do not establish the precise circumstances of the deployments, whether adequate warnings were given or whether any participants sustained injuries. These matters require independent investigation.
Application of treason and national security legislation
Article 192 of Law No. 1 of 2023 criminalises makar committed with the intention of bringing part or all of Indonesian territory under foreign control or separating territory from the Republic of Indonesia. The provision permits penalties ranging up to 20 years' imprisonment, life imprisonment or death. Its application in connection with the raising of a political flag raises serious questions about the distinction between protected political expression and conduct that may legitimately be prosecuted as a national security offence.
Under international human rights law, the peaceful expression of support for independence, autonomy or constitutional change cannot automatically be equated with criminal conduct. The government may protect national security and territorial integrity through lawful and proportionate measures, but restrictions on political expression must satisfy the strict requirements of Article 19(3) of the ICCPR. A prosecution based primarily on the symbolic display of a flag, without credible evidence of criminal acts satisfying the statutory elements of the offence, would risk criminalising political opinion itself.
Article 234 of the Criminal Code concerns acts of damaging, tearing, trampling, burning or otherwise dishonouring the Indonesian national flag with the intention of desecrating, insulting or degrading its dignity. The available reports document the raising of the Morning Star flag but contain no substantiated allegation that the accused damaged or desecrated the Indonesian national flag. The evidentiary and legal basis for invoking Article 234 therefore remains unclear. Investigators should be required to identify the specific conduct attributed to each suspect and demonstrate how it satisfies the statutory elements of the alleged offence.
The severity of the penalties applicable under Article 192 is especially concerning in a case arising from a student demonstration. The authorities must ensure that criminal law is not used to impose disproportionate punishment for the peaceful expression of political beliefs. The possibility of a capital sentence also engages the protections of Article 6 of the ICCPR, which strictly limits the death penalty to the most serious crimes, understood by the Human Rights Committee as crimes of extreme gravity involving intentional killing. Applying a capital sentence to non-lethal political expression would be incompatible with that standard.
Arrest, detention and fair trial guarantees
Article 9 of the ICCPR protects individuals against arbitrary arrest and detention and requires that any deprivation of liberty be lawful, necessary and free from arbitrariness. Article 14 guarantees the right to a fair hearing, the presumption of innocence, adequate time and facilities to prepare a defence, and access to legal assistance. The reported presence of legal representatives during police questioning is an important procedural safeguard. Nevertheless, the initial grounds for the students' arrest, the legal basis for any continued detention, and the extent of judicial oversight have not been established.
The designation of three students as suspects following a political protest must not be treated as evidence of guilt. Police and prosecutors must assess the available evidence individually and ensure that criminal proceedings are not driven by the students' political opinions, their role in organising the demonstration or their association with symbols of Papuan identity. If the arrests or detention were based solely on protected expressive activity, they would raise serious concerns of arbitrariness under Article 9 of the ICCPR.
Academic freedom and the protection of political debate
The incident further raises concerns regarding academic freedom and the obligation of universities to safeguard an environment conducive to independent inquiry and political discussion. Article 13 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) protects the right to education, while the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights has identified academic freedom as an essential component of higher education. Indonesian Law No. 12 of 2012 on Higher Education also recognises academic freedom and academic forum freedoms, subject to their applicable legal framework.
The disagreement between the university rector and student representatives demonstrates the need for transparent institutional procedures and independent verification of disputed facts. University administrators should refrain from publicly stigmatising students or attributing external political affiliations without reliable evidence. In cooperation with students and their legal representatives, the university should ensure that criminal proceedings do not result in unjustified restrictions on access to education, academic participation or lawful political expression.
Detailed case data
Document ID: HRM-CAS-155-2026
Region: Indonesia > Papua > Jayapura > Abepura
Total number of victims: 4
1. Inios Enembe, male unknown Student arbitrary detention, criminalisation, freedom of assembly, freedom of expression
2. Apniel Yagani, male unknown Student arbitrary detention, criminalisation, freedom of assembly, freedom of expression
3. Mikael Obaipa, male unknown Student arbitrary detention, criminalisation, freedom of assembly, freedom of expression
4. Frengky Salak, male unknown Student arbitrary detention, freedom of assembly, freedom of expression
Period of incident: 30/09/2026-01/10/2026
Perpetrator: Republic Indonesia > Indonesian Security Forces > Indonesian Police
Issues: indigenous peoples
Sources: Jubi
