APSN Banner

Capital idea, Indonesia. Now for some reality

Source
Bangkok Post - August 21, 2024

Daniel Moss – Capital cities don't just happen. They develop slowly over decades, perhaps centuries, before resembling their creator's dream – if they ever do. Indonesia is discovering such massive endeavours are hard work and prone to delays. Economics has an annoying habit of intruding.

Some of the hype has been deflated from Nusantara, the US$30 billion (1 trillion baht) administrative centre that Indonesian President Joko Widodo made one of his signature projects. Erecting the city from scratch in the equatorial forests of Borneo was always going to be arduous. In the past week, authorities made two important concessions: the settlement may not be ready for the first batch of civil servants, and the guest list for National Day celebrations had to be scaled back owing to a lack of catering and lodging.

During a visit to the site about 18 months ago, I recognised that the timetable laid out by Mr Widodo would take some doing. There were lots of dirt tracks and trucks, but actual construction was hard to spot. Roads leading to the area from Balikpapan, the nearest urban area, were narrow. Work has progressed since then, but not as much as hoped.

Looming over the project is the approaching end of Mr Widodo's second term in October. His successor, Prabowo Subianto, says he is a fan of Nusantara. The challenge is that the capital isn't coming cheap, and Mr Prabowo has plenty of his own grand plans. Hard choices await.

Mr Widodo has handed him a budget that's in decent shape. The deficit for 2025 is projected to be 2.5% of gross domestic product, safely within the 3% legal limit, the government announced on Friday. The outgoing leader is considered to have run a sound fiscal policy during his decade in office.

Mr Widodo has been aided in this task by Finance Minister Sri Mulyani Indrawati, who is highly regarded by foreign investors. The one truly risky move during the peak of the pandemic was the central bank's direct purchase of bonds from the government – a monetisation of debt. That was a practice long shunned in polite economic circles. In a more normal environment, such a step may not be so easily forgiven.

Mr Prabowo, a former top general, has bristled at spending restraints and has pledged a major boost to economic growth. He wants an annual increase in GDP of 8%; the figure has been closer to 5% over the past decade. It's hard to know whether he really believes this is possible or merely an expression of his ambition. Every time Mr Prabowo expresses frustration at Indonesia's narrow path, aides clean up the mess by expressing fealty to the rules and tamping down market anxiety. His choice of finance minister will be critical.

The president-elect has promised to finish Nusantara, the first stage of which was scheduled for completion this year. Mr Widodo envisages close to two million people living and working there by 2045. How deep is this commitment? "I've told him Nusantara development will take 10, 15, 20 years," Mr Widodo told reporters last week. "He said 'that's not fast enough for me – I want four, five, six years.' It's up to him." Taken at face value, this puts stress on Mr Prabowo's own agenda, including a $29 billion pledge of free meals for schoolchildren.

The idea of moving the capital from Jakarta, which is congested and sinking, is a sound one. But a whole new place, a few hours flight away on a very different island? This isn't like getting the Acela train service between New York and Washington or the three-hour drive from Sydney to Canberra. I grew up in Canberra and lived in DC. These settlements take a while to get going and can never be free of vested interests.

The good news is that a degree of reality is intruding on Nusantara. There should be no rush to the finish. Canberra was selected as the site of Australia's capital in 1913, but construction was hampered by two world wars and depression. Washington was burned by the British during the War of 1812.

Building capital cities from the ground up proceeds in fits and starts. Far better to take a measured approach than to hasten as Brazil did in the late 1950s with Brasilia. The city was one of the massive projects favoured by President Juscelino Kubitschek. They left a legacy of rapid inflation and high debt; an economic crisis that followed ushered in years of military rule.

That's not what Mr Prabowo, the former son-in-law of disgraced autocrat Suharto, wants on his record. This is government, not a sprint.

[Daniel Moss is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering Asian economies. Previously, he was executive editor for economics at Bloomberg News.]

Source: https://www.bangkokpost.com/opinion/2850773/capital-idea-indonesia-now-for-some-realit

Country