Jakarta – Foreign Minister Armanatha Nasir, speaking at the 49th ASEAN Summit in Manila, Philippines, stated that the forest and land fires (karhutla) had been resolved thanks to President Prabowo's strong commitment to addressing the issue. This statement, however, ignores the fact that karhutla and its impacts are still being felt by the public to this day. The disappearance of the smoke does not mean that the public's suffering has come to an end.
The intensity of forest and land fires has indeed decreased, but that does not mean the fires have completely stopped. WALHI's spatial analysis for the period November 1-8, 2026, still identified 1,433 high-confidence hotspots, with the highest concentration – 492 hotspots – in South Papua. Even as of November 14, 2026, the National Disaster Management Agency (BNPB) was still fighting forest and land fires covering an area of 254.89 hectares in Central Kalimantan. The spread and increasing severity of these fires cannot be separated from the government's weak commitment to early prevention and mitigation efforts. Therefore, the government should not be quick to declare that the forest and land fires have ended simply because the flames have begun to die down and smoke is no longer visible. This is because the social, economic, health, and ecological impacts of forest and land fires are far more long-lasting and complex than the fires themselves.
Umi Ma'rufah, a forest and plantation advocate at WALHI, stated, "It's nonsense for the government to say that the forest and land fires are over. The smoke has indeed decreased, but the fires are still burning as we speak. Even as the Foreign Minister declared the fires over, at the very same time, the National Disaster Management Agency (BNPB) was still fighting fires in Central Kalimantan. The reduction in smoke does not automatically eliminate the suffering of the people or restore the environmental damage that has already occurred. The people still have to bear economic losses, health problems, the loss of livelihoods, and damage to ecosystems that will take a long time to recover."
From an economic perspective, many people have lost their farmlands and plantations to the fires. Quite a few have lost their livelihoods and are struggling to continue their businesses because their productive land has been damaged. From a health perspective, people are still suffering from respiratory problems or acute respiratory infections (ARI). This is especially true for people with pre-existing conditions such as tuberculosis (TB); exposure to smoke and deteriorating environmental conditions can exacerbate their illnesses. These health issues do not automatically resolve once the smoke clears and can recur upon exposure to triggers.
"From an ecological perspective, we have lost many wild animals that perished in the fires because they were unable to escape. The loss of forest cover and the large-scale destruction of peatland ecosystems have also diminished nature's ability to absorb and store carbon. These conditions are further exacerbating the climate crisis. Ultimately, the climate crisis will increase the risk of extreme weather, crop failures, water crises, and various other ecological disasters," Umi said firmly.
Furthermore, WALHI believes the government has not demonstrated sufficient commitment to ensuring a comprehensive response to forest and land fires. Law enforcement against arsonists remains weak, while monitoring of fire-prone areas has not been effective. The response to forest and land fires in several regions is still far from adequate. In Papua, for example, communities have had to face raging fires and the loss of their livelihoods without adequate support from the government. As a result, they have been forced to fend for themselves in the face of the fires and their consequences.
The problems did not end once the fire was successfully extinguished. WALHI is also concerned that the areas previously affected by the fire will be converted into oil palm plantations. These concerns are growing in light of the government's agenda to promote energy security through the development of B50 biodiesel, which requires a large-scale supply of palm oil. Without forest protection, strict oversight, and ecosystem restoration, this agenda risks accelerating the expansion of oil palm plantations – including into areas previously affected by fires. Rather than restoring the environment, the government risks perpetuating ecological damage through land-use changes.
"The government should not measure the success of its response to forest and land fires solely by the disappearance of smoke or the extinguishing of the fires. Success should be measured by the restoration of people's livelihoods, the fulfillment of victims' rights, the enforcement of the law, and the restoration of damaged ecosystems. As long as communities continue to bear the impact of forest and land fires and ecological damage persists, the forest and land fire crisis cannot be declared over," "That's all," said Umi.
Indonesian Environmental Agency14 Tegal Parang Utara Street, Mampang Prapatan, South Jakarta
Email: informasi@walhi.or.id, Instagram: @walhi.nasional, X: @walhi.nasional
TikTok: @walhi.nasional
Cell Phone: (+628115501980)
