The recurring forest and land fires (karhutla) in various regions of Sumatra indicate that the ecological crisis has not yet been addressed at its root. Karhutla is not merely a seasonal disaster that ends once the fires are extinguished. Underlying these fires are issues of ecosystem degradation, land-use planning, land tenure, weak corporate oversight, and the loss of habitats for both communities and wildlife.
Through public discussions "Young People Restore Indonesia: Recurring Forest and Land Fires Put Ecological Justice at Stake", Disaster Response Teams from various regions in Sumatra highlighted the importance of the government's role in prevention, response, and post-forest-and-land-fire recovery. The discussion also emphasized that recovery efforts should not focus solely on the burned forest and land areas, but must address all the ecological, social, economic, and health impacts experienced by the community.
Abdul Hadi Lubis (Riau Disaster Response Desk Coordinator) emphasizes that the shutdown is not a solution as long as the damage to the water management system and the ecological functions of the peatlands have not been restored.
"As long as the damage to the water management system and the ecological functions of the peatlands remains unrepaired, fire suppression will only be a temporary solution, and the threat of fires will continue to recur. The government must ensure that corporations genuinely fulfill their environmental restoration responsibilities, rather than allowing communities to continue bearing the brunt of the same damage year after year."
Meanwhile, Muhammad Tsani (Jambi Disaster Response Coordinator) He highlighted forest and land fires as an issue of land-use management and law enforcement. In his view, efforts to address forest and land fires must hold corporations accountable, rather than stopping at taking action against individuals.
"The forest and land fires in Jambi are not a natural disaster, but rather an issue of land-use management and law enforcement. The government must not stop at naming individual suspects. It must investigate corporate liability, enforce the law without exception, and ensure that environmental restoration takes place."
From South Sumatra, Suci Indah (South Sumatra Disaster Desk) emphasizes that the community bears the brunt of the impacts of forest and land fires, ranging from smoke exposure and the loss of livelihoods to environmental damage.
"The community endures smoke, the loss of livelihoods, and environmental damage. The government must be present not only when fires rage, but also to ensure the protection of the public–especially women, children, and other vulnerable groups–as well as corporate oversight and equitable land use. As young people, we must continue to speak out and fight against ecological injustice."
The issue of forest and land fires also threatens the sustainability of conservation areas and biodiversity. Dedi Kurniawan (Lampung Disaster Desk) It is worth noting that the recurring fires in Way Kambas National Park (TNWK) highlight the weakness of protection measures in conservation areas.
"The recurring forest and land fires in Way Kambas National Park highlight the weakness of protection measures for conservation areas. The fires destroy habitats and reduce wildlife's range, thereby increasing the risk of conflict between wildlife and humans."
Furthermore, Rifki Sya'ban (Jakarta Disaster Desk) emphasized that post-forest-and-land-fire recovery must be comprehensive, encompassing ecosystems, communities, and wildlife.
"The government must ensure the restoration of ecosystems and the living spaces of communities affected by forest and land fires, including the restoration of water sources and agricultural land, as well as the sustainability of communities' social and economic lives. The government must also ensure the protection of wildlife through rescue, rehabilitation, and habitat restoration efforts. All restoration efforts must be directed toward restoring the balance and ecological functions of forests as a unified ecosystem that sustains human life and biodiversity."
Concluding the series of statements, Wahdan Lubis (Coordinator of the Sumatra Regional Disaster Desk) emphasized that the government must be present throughout all stages of a disaster, not just when a fire breaks out.
"The government must be present before, during, and after forest and land fires occur in Sumatra and in several other regions of Indonesia. The government's role is not only to extinguish the fires, but also to prevent the recurrence of forest and land fires, protect the people during a crisis, and ensure comprehensive recovery afterward. Recovery must not stop at the burned forests and lands, but must extend to the people's disrupted lives–from their health, livelihoods, and living spaces to the social fabric of their communities. When forest and land fires destroy people's lives, the recovery process must also restore every aspect of their lives."
These various issues demonstrate that the forest and land fire crisis cannot be resolved solely through fire suppression and emergency response. What is needed is a change in governance that ensures the protection of ecosystems, the enforcement of the law against those responsible, environmental restoration, and the recovery of the livelihoods of affected communities.
Through this public discussion, young people emphasized that Indonesia's future is inextricably linked to ecological justice. Young people must play a role in holding the government accountable, critiquing governance practices that harm the environment, and advocating for recovery efforts that prioritize the people and the sustainability of ecosystems.
Young People, Let's Rebuild Indonesia!Wahdan Lubis (Coordinator of the Sumatra Regional Disaster Desk)0853 6762 7442
Source: https://www.walhi.or.id/en/karhutla-berulang-keadilan-ekologis-dipertaruhka
