APSN Banner

Why Dairi residents protest environmental permit for zinc, lead mining

Source
Tempo - November 13, 2026

Sahat Simatupang, Jakarta – Hundreds of residents of Dairi, North Sumatra, called on Regent Vickner Sinaga to request the Minister of Environment to cancel the environmental permit of PT Dairi Prima Mineral (DPM), a zinc and lead mining company. The residents staged a protest at the Dairi Regent's Office on Thursday, November 12, 2026.

Resident representative Sandi Panjaitan said Regent Vickner made the wrong move by converting the spatial planning of Dairi Regency from a functional rice field area to a mining area. The new spatial planning was approved by the Dairi Regency Government, which then based the reissuance of the environmental permit or the decision letter of environmental feasibility (SKKLH) of the mining company.

The spatial planning shift also affects the agricultural land owned by thousands of farmers across ten villages located near the DPM mining site. "The decision transforms the farmland, which has been the primary livelihood of the residents, into a mining area owned by DPM," he said.

According to Sandi, the agricultural land in Pandiangan Village, Lae Parira District, North Sumatra, covers 14 thousand hectares, half of which are now occupied by Dairi Prima Mineral.

Residents of Dairi are now challenging the environmental permit in the State Administrative Court of Jakarta, Sandi said, adding that no permit would have been issued if the regent did not change the spatial planning. "If the residents lose the lawsuit, the agricultural land will turn into a mining area," he cautioned.

By the time the protest ended, Regent Vickner and Deputy Regent Wahyu Daniel Sagala had not engaged with the residents, who denied the official appointed to meet them. "We only want to meet the regent and the deputy regent because the spatial planning of Dairi is their doing," said Sandi.

Besides Dairi, Sandi said protests against the DPM permit were also held at the Jakarta Administrative Court on Thursday, coinciding with the trial. Dairi residents ask for the court to order the temporary suspension of DPM's activities, as well as to annul the latest approval or environmental permit from the Ministry of Environment.

Representatives of Dairi residents who live newar the mining site present during the trial include Darwin Situmorang, Tioman Simangunsong, and Raini Purba. They were accompanied by the North Sumatra Legal Aid and Advocacy Association (Bakumsu).

The Executive Director of Bakumsu, Juniaty Aritonang, explained that the mining permit for DPM was revoked in 2024 through a Supreme Court decision that ruled in favor of Dairi residents. Issued on August 12, 2024, the decision granted all residents' lawsuits and declared invalid the Minister of Environment and Forestry's Decree No. SK.854/MENLHK/SETJEN/PLA.4/8/2022 regarding the environmental feasibility of Dairi Prima Mineral's zinc and lead mining activities.

"If the Jakarta Administrative Court favors PT DPM in the new lawsuit we filed, it means the supremacy of law is defeated even though the residents have won in the Supreme Court in 2024," said Juniaty to Tempo.

Deputy Manager of External Relations at PT DPM, Baiq Idayani, said the company fully respects the ongoing legal process, but said the permit for the Addendum to the Environmental Impact Analysis (Adendum AMDAL) contained in SKKLH No. 1437 of 2026 did not disregard previous court decisions.

An environmental permit is mandatory for every mining company, thus, the subject of dispute in the previous court ruling must be legally distinguished from the SKKLH issued in 2026.

The 2024 Supreme Court ruling also did not eliminate PT DPM's obligation to obtain environmental permits to carry out its operations. Baiq said the latest SKKLH provides instructions on the form of approval for adjustment of environmental documents due to changes in the mining design, namely the backfilling method with modern and tactical techniques by processing waste and utilizing it as material to close former underground mining voids.

"There is no longer a facility for permanent tailing placement on land that requires a large area," Baiq said.

Regardless, Baiq said the 2026 SKKLH issued by the Ministry of Environment was reviewed and implemented according to the applicable legal framework. The new permit was submitted based on technical studies, risk management, monitoring, and compliance with all environmental requirements set by the government, supported by scientific documents and accountable process stages, according to the representative of DPM.

Source: https://en.tempo.co/read/2123567/why-dairi-residents-protest-environmental-permit-for-zinc-lead-minin

Country