This is what happens when wiretapping is used to serve personal or group interests. Without adequate regulations, the police eavesdrop on people's conversations – not for law enforcement purposes, but to spy on them and map out who is an ally and who is an adversary.
The wiretapping of President Prabowo Subianto, politicians, businesspeople, activists, and journalists is one example. The police have accused Presidential Chief of Staff Listyo Sigit Prabowo and three other generals of being behind the interception of thousands of telephone numbers. The wiretapping took place from 2025 through October 2026, while Listyo was still serving as National Police Chief.
On Listyo's orders, the generals entered telephone numbers into the Lawful Interception Management System (LIMS) even though the numbers had no connection to any legal cases. In addition to Listyo, the police have named Insp. Gen. Ahrie Sonta Nasution, Insp. Gen. Eko Hadi Santoso, and Insp. Gen. Slamet Uliandi as suspects. The Presidential Palace has accused them of plotting treason
Without independent oversight, wiretapping equipment is vulnerable to abuse. This is especially true when interception powers are held by institutions with weak internal supervision, such as the police, intelligence agencies, and other law enforcement bodies. It is entirely possible that intercepted communications could be used as bargaining chips to bring political opponents into line.
The root of the problem is the absence of a dedicated law governing wiretapping. Regulations on communications interception are currently scattered across several laws, from the Electronic Information and Transactions (ITE) Law and the Telecommunications Law to the Corruption Eradication Commission Law, as well as the internal regulations of various institutions.
Although wiretapping for law enforcement purposes is exempt from the prohibition, provisions on who authorizes interception, how long it may last, and how intercepted data must be monitored are not consistent across regulations. Those with access to surveillance equipment have exploited these legal loopholes to serve their own groups' interests.
That is why, as far back as 2010, the Constitutional Court ordered that wiretapping procedures – including the duration of interception, oversight, and audit mechanisms – be governed by a separate law. The aim was to ensure transparency and accountability. Sixteen years later, the Wiretapping Bill remains stalled in the House of Representatives.
The Siracusa Principles could serve as a reference. Governments must not conduct wiretapping – as a form of interference with the right to privacy – arbitrarily. In 1984, international law experts formulated guidelines on when states may restrict rights under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, including the right to privacy in communications.
Such restrictions are necessary to ensure that interception has a clear legal basis and a legitimate purpose, meets the test of necessity, and is carried out proportionately – in other words, in a manner commensurate with the objective being pursued. These principles provide a framework for independent oversight, multilayered audits, and remedies in cases of abuse. Wiretapping practices in Indonesia have strayed from that framework.
Surveillance equipment is frequently misused to suppress criticism from civil society and groups on the opposing side. Consider what happened in 2019, when opposition to revisions to the Corruption Eradication Commission Law was mounting. Mobile phones and social media accounts were not only hijacked, activists were also subjected to wiretapping. Such practices stifle civil liberties. Democracy is on the brink.
The procurement of surveillance equipment is funded with public money. Indonesia Corruption Watch and Trend Asia found 376 police surveillance technology procurement packages worth Rp35.9 trillion between 2013 and 2026. The use of wiretapping equipment should therefore be subject to the principles of accountability and transparency to prevent it from being abused for political purposes.
The investigation into illegal wiretapping must not stop with Listyo and his associates. Interception on such a large scale could hardly have been carried out by technical operators alone. Legal proceedings must reach the auctor intellectualis – the masterminds – and uncover the interests behind the operation. Stopping with those already named as suspects would leave the structural weaknesses in the wiretapping system untouched.
Wiretapping requires strict regulations covering everything from authorization and oversight mechanisms to penalties for abuse. Without proper governance, wiretapping in Indonesia will remain a lawless jungle, serving as a tool of intimidation and political power.
– Read the complete story in Tempo English Magazine
Source: https://en.tempo.co/read/2123335/indonesias-wild-west-of-wiretappin
